Quick answer: FBR’s draft SRO dated 18 November 2026 proposes adding Chapter XIXA (Faceless Appeals) to the Income Tax Rules, 2002. Appeals under section 127 would be filed on the IRIS e-portal, randomly allocated to anonymous Commissioners (Appeals), heard by video-conference, and decided through DIN-stamped electronic orders. The Chapter starts on a date notified by the Board.
From faceless audit to faceless appeals
FBR has already moved audits to a faceless model, and the Finance Act 2026 brought a faceless audit, assessment and appeal framework into the Sales Tax Act. The draft amendments extend the same approach to income tax appeals by adding an Appeals Wing to the Center (rule 235) and a new Chapter XIXA.
Key proposals
- Scope and commencement (245A): applies to section 127 appeals processed through the Center; date set by Gazette notification, possibly different dates for different classes. Pending appeals stay with the same Commissioner unless the Board transfers them. The option to appeal directly to the Appellate Tribunal is preserved.
- Appeals Wing (245C): Appellate Units headed by Commissioners (Appeals) under the Member (Legal) Inland Revenue; officers who did the audit or passed the order cannot hear the appeal.
- E-filing and allocation (245D-E): filing on the IRIS portal, unique appeal number, random automated allocation, identities hidden; reallocation logged with reasons.
- Respondent (245F): the Commissioner of the relevant Wing, or the jurisdictional Commissioner, files parawise comments through the system within seven days of requisition (or as allowed).
- Procedure (245G): all notices and submissions electronic; no personal appearance; documents uploaded as verified scanned copies; originals may be verified by Field Operations Wing.
- Stay applications (245H): filed and heard electronically.
- E-hearings (245I): video-conference, Commissioner’s face not shown and voice modulated; option to be decided on written submissions; proceedings recorded; appellants without internet may use an e-hearing room at the nearest Field Operations unit.
- Orders (245J): system-generated with DIN, no name or signature; served on your designated account; Tribunal appeals cite appeal number and DIN.
- System failure (245L): a portal outage confirmed by the Board is sufficient cause for delay.
- Instructions (245M): the Board may issue SOPs and formats.
What should taxpayers do now?
- Submit objections or suggestions within 3 days of Gazette publication (draft stage).
- Check your IRIS profile and registered email/mobile.
- Keep appeal documents digitized and verifiable.
- Prepare written submissions as carefully as oral arguments.
FAQs
What is a faceless appeal?
An appeal under section 127 filed, allocated, heard and decided electronically, without in-person contact or disclosed identities.
When will it start?
On a date notified by the Board in the Gazette; these are still draft rules.
Can I still go directly to the Appellate Tribunal?
Yes, the draft preserves the option under the proviso to section 127(1).
Will I attend hearings in person?
No; e-hearings by video, with access to an e-hearing room if you lack internet.
Need help? BTaxFiler helps with appeals, notice replies, returns and compliance. WhatsApp 0328 9477707 | support@btaxfiler.com | Second floor, Plaza 170, Sector G, DHA-1, Lahore. See also FBR.
Disclaimer: Based on a draft notification; provisions may change before final notification. General information, not legal advice.